Still, with the support of sisters heather sarah paulson and caroline poppy montgomery and carolines fiance, jeff joe flanigan, carla. Although this is case, the film also challenges many of these stereotypes as well. Sheltered by going to a special private boarding school. As they fall in love, carlas mother becomes nervous. This is a sweet love story about two special people finding themselves and each other. Despite the vibrant performances of juliette lewis and giovanni ribisi and some touching scenes between the two, the other sister is predictable, sentimental, and very heavyhanded. The other sister 1999 reinforced stereotypes jasmeets. This week in class, we watched a movie that differed in the usual genres we have been viewing. The following is a brief summary of the content found in this pg rated film.
Request pdf on feb 1, 2000, j h hammer and others published transitioning individuals with mental retardation and developmental disability. The movie the other sister is a romantic comedy released by touchstone pictures in 1999 by director garry marshall about carla tate juliette lewis a 22 year old woman who is developmentally delayed and her struggles and accomplishments she has showing her family her father dr. Apr 05, 2014 the other sister is a great film about intellectual disabilites, but it tends to reinforce many stereotypes about individuals who have a disability. The other sister 1999 carla tate juliette lewis has never been like her sisters. Carla wants to be independent and wants to live alone like danny. Although the exact diagnosis of the protagonist, carla tate is never revealed throughout the film, she is very high functioning. The other sister is a 1999 american romantic comedy film directed by garry marshall and stars juliette lewis, giovanni ribisi, diane keaton, and tom skerritt. On another level, it also shows a very dark side of humanity, as most of the main characters are deeply flawed, and in some cases, utterly. While carlas mother hopes to reconnect with her daughter, carla has other plans. One of the obvious stereotypes being that those with disabilities always need to be dependent on someone, which isnt the case in this film. Because carla has such a happy go lucky and can do personality, it would be hard for a viewer of any age to not be smiling throughout the entire film. Charlie works at donners bakery in new york city as a janitor and delivery boy.
The other sister is a romantic comedydrama about the special relationship between two mentally impaired young people carla juliette lewis, who just came back from 8 years in a special school, and wanted to prove she can now handle her life on her own and be independent, and daniel giovanni ribi. I use the movie the other sister in my classes for several reasons. Johnson is positive she can thrive there, despite elizabeths. Aug 28, 2018 the other sister by sarah zettel is a highly recommended psychological thriller featuring the dynamics of twisted dysfunctional family. The contents of this case study were developed under a grant from. She has two sisters, whom she frequently talks to, and a mother and father that are still married. The other sister is a romantic comedy starring juliet lewis as carla tate, a young woman with an intellectual disability who moves home to san francisco, from a special boarding school for those with disabilities. Dec 09, 2014 the other sister is about a girl with an intellectual disability named carla tate.
Good acting and even entretaining, but the other sister present a strong sentimentalism and an embarrassing way to use the mental problems as a good plot. This documentary, created by lauren gill and sophiya pradham, describes and demonstrates how carla tate from the other sister displays symptoms of intellectual disability, also known as mental. Feb 23, 2015 similar to most girls, my ideal movie choice is usually some sort of a romance film. By institutionalizing carla, it actually harmed her. In the other sister we see carla and daniel being shown and reffered to. I found the ringer to be thoroughly entertaining, and found many correlations between it and last weeks film, freaks. The other employees often taunt him and pick on him, but charlie is unable to understand that he is the subject of mockery. Sep 25, 20 this documentary, created by lauren gill and sophiya pradham, describes and demonstrates how carla tate from the other sister displays symptoms of intellectual disability, also known as mental. He may have learning disabilities, such as written expression as demonstrated in his progris. Mental retardation abnormal psychology lumen learning. Carla, played by juliette lewis, returns home after spending years at a school for children with disabilities.
Diane keaton, juliette lewis, tom skerritt, giovanni ribisi, poppy montgomery, sarah paulson, joe flanigan, juliet mills, hector. On the health and well being of people with intellectual disability, i think society perceives them as baliw or sira ulo thus they tend to avoid them while others view them as a source of entertainment. Similar to most girls, my ideal movie choice is usually some sort of a romance film. Carla tate was institutionalized for 10 years at the roseland school because her mom thought she needed professional help. Early and intense intervention is the only cure if you must call it that for the down populationas it is for any other disability. Carla became extremely self conscious due to the fact that the boys would tease her. An implied sexual encounter occurs between the two central characters, as well as other nonexplicit, sexually related talk which includes their use and discussion of a sex manual. The other sister is a romantic comedydrama about the special relationship between two mentally impaired young people carla juliette lewis, who just came back from 8 years in a special school, and wanted to prove she can now handle her life on her own and be independent, and daniel giov.
Geraldine and marie monroe are sisters with a plan. It was filmed in long beach, pasadena, and san francisco, california. It explores the disability of two people who are in love and the stereotypes that evolve because of their disabilities. The movie is meant to be a heartwarming family movie, but modern politically correct sermonizing creeps in to mar its good intentions, and the movie veers too often toward the prosaic. The other sister reflection this movie portrays how a family, who has a member with a disability, encountered and overcame adversities from within triggered by several environmental factors. They arent anywhere near as close in age with each other or her as you and your brother but it has truly been.
She wants to attend a public vocational school, and dr. Their zingers slide out with the precision of sitcom. Nearly one third of united states more than 20 million have at least one a disability. Diane keaton, juliette lewis, tom skerritt, giovanni ribisi, poppy montgomery, sarah paulson, joe flanigan, juliet mills, hector elizondo, linda thorson. In the beginning of this film, we see carlas father radley tate picking up carla from boarding school. Poet laureate, 20012003 poetry and literature, library of congress.
Barriers being accepted by her mother for who she was. The two grew up in michigan in an emotionally abusive household with a manipulative, cruel father, martin, and an alcoholic mother, stacy. Carla is welcomed home by her family, and her sister, caroline poppy montgomery, announces shes engaged to be married to her fiance, jeff reed joe flanigan. The other sister is a 1999 film directed by garry marshall, about a mentally disabled woman named carla juliette lewis, who meets and falls in love with a mentally disabled man named daniel giovanni ribisi, while trying to live independently from her mother diane keaton. Transitioning individuals with mental retardation and developmental disability. The family members may also look at them as a disgrace to the family. I instantly gravitated to the other sister because of its sure to make me cry storyline. The other sister jh hammer, j holloway, dk deprato and kj weiss journal of the american academy of psychiatry and the law online june 2000, 28 2 202205. The other sister challenging stereotypes monicasaggu. Carla, played by juliette lewis, returns home after.
Disability the number of adults with intellectual or development disabilities age 60 or over who live in the community is estimated to double to 1. The other sister is about a girl with an intellectual disability named carla tate. Nov 26, 2014 it is funny to see a role reversal, because in high school and other social settings, it is often the normal personpeople who are rude to those with disability. The film follows carla tate, a twentytwo year old woman with an intellectual disability, as she comes home to her wealthy family in northern california after graduating from a training school for the mentally challenged. The protagonist, carla tate, who has an intellectual disability, seeks freedom from her mother, acceptance from others, and attentionlove from opposite sex. This film increased my sensitivity to the needs of people with disabilities in many. Apr 05, 2014 like many other disability films, the other sister tends to portray disabled persons in a very stereotypical way.
The other sister follows carla, a young adult who has a disability although not specified in the film. Qualitative content analysis was used for the analysis of the transcribed texts. Jun 20, 2012 reflection paper 1 the other sister jun 20 by ot170 the other sister from the title itself it seems to single out a person from the rest of the family, in this case it was carla tate a girl with a condition. It has also shed light about how they affect others lives especially. The movie is basically a mixture of a romantic comedy and a dramedy. Her mother elizabeth tate, who likes to controll carlas behavior, is played by diane keaton. Carlas family had struggled with her as a child and ultimately decided to send her to a boarding school that was highly specialized in dealing with her disability. Our other sister, by jeffrey harrison poem 174 of poetry 180. The other sister by sarah zettel is a highly recommended psychological thriller featuring the dynamics of twisted dysfunctional family. Dec 05, 2014 this week in class, we watched a movie that differed in the usual genres we have been viewing.
The other sister is a romantic comedy starring juliet lewis as carla tate, a young woman with an intellectual disability who moves home to san francisco, from a. A reflection paper the movie the other sister has given its viewers a small glimpse about how mentally challenged human beings face the ups and downs of their lives. A poem a day for american high schools, hosted by billy collins, u. Because carla has such a happy go lucky and can do personality, it would be hard for a viewer of. The other sister an overprotective mother shelters carla, a young woman with an intellectual disability id. The other sister 1999 challenged stereotypes jasmeet. Transitioning individuals with mental retardation and. It treats the characters like cute little performing sealswho always deliver their retarded dialogue with perfect timing and an edge of irony and drama. Along with the many stereotypes reinforced in the film, the other sister, there are many stereotypes that are challenged. The film begins with lead character steve, played by johnny knoxville at a job that leaves him unhappy, until he is promoted. The other sister is a romantic comedydrama about the special relationship.
The other sister the other sister, starring juliette lewis as carla tate, portrays the journey of a mildly mentally challenged young woman. Anyone with any knowledge of retardation is likely to find the film offensive. Carla wants to become more independent, so she moves into her own apartment and enrolls in a local vocational college. The modes of representation regarding disabled people in films includes them being portrayed as childlike, dependent and asexual.
All in all, the other sister was an excellent movie. She initially shows great concern for gregor, but her compassion gives way to possessiveness and resentment as the effects of gregors transformation on her life slowly take their toll. During family discussions, elizabeth adopts an uneasy attitude. Carla tate a case study in intellectual disability youtube. This week in class we viewed the ringer, starring johnny knoxville and katherine heigl. The movie is meant to be a heartwarming family movie, but modern politically correct sermonizing creeps in to mar its good intentions, and. The other sister is shameless in its use of mental retardation as a gimmick, a prop and a plot device. The other sister is a 1999 film directed by garry marshall, about a mentally disabled woman named carla juliette lewis, who meets and falls in love with a mentally disabled man named daniel giovanni ribisi, while trying to live independently from her mother diane keaton the movie is basically a mixture of a romantic comedy and a dramedy. For starters, people with disabilities are often shown as being isolated from the rest of society. At the start of the other sister, carla tate juliette lewis, a mildly retarded. Siblings experiences of having a sense of responsibility for their brother or sister varied in different ages and in different families.
Reviewed in the united kingdom on january 20, 2020. The other sister follows carla, a young adult who has a disability although not specified in. Our other sister, by jeffrey harrison poem 174 poetry 180. Sent at a young age to a school for children with intellectual impairments, a maturing carla returns to her. The other sister 1999 reinforced stereotypes jasmeet. This film portrays a young woman with a mild mental disability. Much of the conflict comes from their resentment of each other, but also their inability to live without the other. The other sister is a standard hollywood wedding movie kind of a father of the bride with mentallyhandicapped people. The other sister centers around the lovehate relationship between two adult twin sisters. Sep 25, 2012 siblings with special needs change childhood. The sibling talks about his feelings and how they help each other when his sister has to have a hospital stay. The other sister is about a family with a sibling that has a developmental disability also known as mildly mentally retardation mmr, mild developmental disability, or mild intellectual disorder mid. The other sister reinforcing stereotypes monicasaggu. Radley tate tom skerritt, her mother elizabeth tate diane.
The other sister reflection essay sample new york essays. Jun 01, 2000 transitioning individuals with mental retardation and developmental disability. In one of the funniest scenes in the film, steve joins the group of 6 friends for lunch at their table, but is met with sarcasm and jokes made at his expense. Carla tate is our main character that has mmr as a disability.
Elizabeth insists that as the mother of a developmentally disabled young woman, she knows more about what works for carla, than carla does. Tobys sister is very brave when she goes into hospital and toby has to learn to be very brave as well. Siblings experiences of having a brother or sister with. Carla hands her mother a bunch of necklaces shed made at the school. Seen as asexual or only being attracted to someone else with a disability. Subtlety and nuance are nowhere to be found in garry marshalls direction, particularly notable in the performances of diane keaton and tom skerritt as carlas. Although we could have gone without seeing the characters sister in bed with her girlfriend, and the implied sexual activity between two unmarried people carla and her boyfriend, i found this movie to be both funny and entertaining. Reflection paper 1 the other sister jun 20 by ot170 the other sister from the title itself it seems to single out a person from the rest of the family, in this case it was carla tate a girl with a condition. Their disabilities did not stop them from living a complete life in a nondisabled world. Johnson counters by explaining that despite her disability, carla is stubbornly independent, and this trait has to be cultivated.
The film the other sister was produced by garry marshall in the year 1999. The sibling of a child with a disability may feel that he or she needs to take care of the brother or sister with disability. A book about dealing with a sibling with long term illness. Our other sister, by jeffrey harrison poem 174 poetry. Like many other disability films, the other sister tends to portray disabled persons in a very stereotypical way. I had big concerns about how the two other kiddos would deal with having a sister who was different.
592 1412 825 757 160 161 1238 1337 1494 1461 1160 75 365 1155 261 452 256 211 1379 405 994 1016 499 1015 1031 1028 1180 877 792 236 154 1275 166 1077 1035 503 344 193 1487 1448 844 214 1168 564 56 1292