Scalia wrote the following passages in the famous king v. Olson, a case decided on june 29, 1988, when he was finishing just his second term on the supreme court. The dissenting opinion scalla 1994 journal of supreme court. If the statutory language is plain, the court must enforce it according to its terms. This volume the first of its kind showcases the quotable justice s take on many of today s most contentious constitutional debates, including. Rare, pristine copy of scalia dissents, boldly signed by. From the courts decisions on gay marriage to obamacare to immigration, scalia, who was known for his wit, challenged them all with pizazz. Moreover, if this is meant to be an equalprotection opinion, it is a confusing one, scalia.
On the radio program your turn meeting nonsense with common sense, the centers general counsel, renee giachino, recently interviewed kevin ring, author of scalia dissents. Writings of the supreme court s wittiest, most outspoken justice read. Scalia dissents is a well curated sample of scalias opinions. Instead, rings expertise developed during his roles in public service as counsel to sen. His father, salvatore eugene scalia 19031986, an italian immigrant from sommatino, sicily, graduated from rutgers university and was a graduate student at columbia university and clerk at the time of his sons birth. March 11, 1936 february, 2016 was an american lawyer, jurist, government official, and academic who served as an associate justice of the. Antonin scalia was married to maureen for fiftyfive years. In scalia dissents, kevin ring, former counsel to the u. Uncharacteristically, the editor of this collection of excerpts from former supreme court justice antonin scalia s 19362016 landmark opinions and dissents is not an academic. Heres a sampling of some of his most notable, and often scathing, dissenting opinions over the years. The late justice antonin scalia thought his best opinion was his dissent in morrison v. Even scalia s dissenting opinions get major scrutiny justice antonin scalia s dissent in the arizona immigration case led a noted liberal to call for his resignation, and a fellow conservative.
He imagined the state laws that justice anthony kennedy. Rare mint condition copy of scalia dissents, boldly signed by justice scalia on the half title page. Affirmative action in the eyes of government, we are just one race. On monday, the supreme court arrived at a complicated. Oct 14, 2014 justice antonin scalia wrote the dissent pdf, joined by justices clarence thomas and ruth bader ginsburg. Supreme court justice antonin scalia, who died saturday, was known for his sharp tongue and piercing pen, qualities that underscored his adeptness at delivering a splashy dissent from the. His dissents in particular were filled with his strong, witty, and punny personality. He was born in catania sicily, but later he moved to switzerland with his parents and attended swissgerman schools until high school. Antonin scalia is the supreme courts greatest writer the.
Writings by justice scalia grouped by type, in alphabetical order by first party name opinions concurrences dissents concur in part, dissent in part. Scalia was perhaps the leading voice of uncompromising conservatism on the supreme court. As a sheer writer, i think, justice scalia belongs in the company of. Todays opinion aggrandizes the power of the court to pronounce the law, scalia wrote in the dissenting opinion. Uncharacteristically, the editor of this collection of excerpts from former supreme court justice antonin scalias 19362016 landmark opinions and dissents is not an academic. A legacy of landmark opinions and dissents, ring collects scalia s most memorable opinions on free speech, separation of powers, race, religious freedom, the rights of the accused, abortion, and more. The present petition presents the nonhypothetical case the court claimed to have been. By a vote of 7to1 anthony kennedy recused, with chief justice william rehnquist writing, the court upheld the statute.
Supreme court justice antonin scalia wrote what has to be some of the best reads in supreme court history. Senate s constitution subcommittee, lets justice scalia speak for himself. Scalia s unusual view of supreme court diversity by many measures, the current supreme court is the most diverse in history. Supreme court justice antonin scalia speaks to presbyterian christian high school students in hattiesburg, miss. It lets scalia do most of the talking, but provides just enough editorial input to give the context for understanding scalias approach. Jun 26, 20 scalia continued to criticize kennedys opinion, calling it confusing on the core issue. The one current justice who has the strongest claim to belong in this elite pantheon is antonin scalia. Syllabus opinion stevens dissent scalia html version pdf version. In the eyes of government, we are just one race here.
Jun 25, 2015 justice antonin scalia wasnt going to go down without a fight a colorful one at that. The supreme court justice kennedy writing for himself and justices ginsburg, breyer, sotomayor, and kagan held that the right to marry is a. His duty, as he described it in his dissent in planned parenthood of southeastern pennsylvania v. Scalias dissent for the ages in the dna case june 4, 20 by jeffrey rosen some of supreme court justice antonin scalias greatest opinions have involved his passionate defense of the fourth amendment right against unreasonable searches and seizures. Justice scalia, with whom justice thomas joins, dissenting.
Justice scalia, originalism and textualism digital commons. Best lines from antonin scalias obamacare dissent cnn. Antonin scalia wikisource, the free online library. Pietro scalia born march 17, 1960 is an italianamerican film editor. Writings of the supreme courts wittiest, most outspoken justice, about the u.
Jun 26, 2015 antonin scalia is the supreme courts greatest writer. In a ripping dissent, scalia says that justice anthony. In 1988, by a vote of 71, the supreme court upheld the. It lets scalia do most of the talking, but provides just enough editorial input to give the context for understanding scalia s approach. Transportation agency in 1987, scalia quoted shakespeare, using an exchange from henry iv to speak about spirits from the vasty deep. Author of scalia dissents shares his views of the supreme court and its wittiest, most outspoken justice. Prior to justice scalia s service on the court, perhaps the high. After his 2009 arrest on first and seconddegree assault. Burwell case on behalf of a threevote minority that included justices samuel alito and clarence thomas.
Most of all, however, scalia, who died on saturday, will be remembered for his scathing dissents. Scalia believes deeply in the textandtradition approach. To take one particularly critical example, the joint dissent to the 2012 us supreme court opinion largely upholding the affordable care act coauthored by scalia was so flagrantly inconsistent. Supreme court justice antonin scalia was known for his dissents in his 29 years on the court, scalia achieved almost a cult following for his acerbic dissents, which in many ways shaped the. The court attacks this fundamental alteration analysis by asking two questions. Scalia, thomas and ginsburg dissent from cert denial in. The dissenting opinion scalla 1994 journal of supreme. Jun 26, 20 in a blistering rebuke of the supreme court decision to overturn the defense of marriage act, justice antonin scalia said the selfgoverning power of the people has been eroded.
Writings of the supreme courts wittiest, most outspoken justice regnery publishing, 2004, 9697. Dissenting from this mornings opinion on the defense of marriage act, justice antonin scalia as expected holds nothing back. The judgment distorts the text of title iii, the structure of the ada, and common sense. A look at the justice antonin scalias most unusual word. Justice scalia s gift as a wordsmith is something he always had.
Supreme court justice antonin scalia, who died saturday, was known for his sharp tongue and piercing pen, qualities that underscored his adeptness at delivering a splashy dissent. S upreme court justice antonin scalia is known for his colorful language, using phrases like arglebargle and jiggerypokery in his dissents but the two harshest words he uses to. Justice antonin scalias most scathing dissent opinions. Feb 14, 2016 supreme court justice antonin scalia, who died saturday, was known for his sharp tongue and piercing pen, qualities that underscored his adeptness at delivering a splashy dissent from the court.
Author ofscalia dissents shares his views of the supreme. Scalia rages against supreme courts gay rights ruling. In my view todays opinion exercises a benevolent compassion that the law does not place it within our power to impose. Scalia dissents is a well curated sample of scalia s opinions. There was perhaps no supreme court justice known more for his biting opinions than justice antonin scalia, who was found dead saturday at the age of 79. And speaking of justice kennedy, the scalia dissent took direct aim at lawrence v.
And there was the historic battle in 2009 involving scalia. Justice scalia s approach to the fourth amendments prohibition on unreasonable searches and seizures provides a useful illustration. Looking at justice scalia s opinions, dissents scalia weighed in on aereo, gps tracking, thermal imaging, drug dogs, gun rights, and dna. Aug 21, 2014 as one example, consider the position of justice antonin scalia. Justice scalia delivered this address as the societys annual lecture on june, 1994. Antonin scalia was born on march 11, 1936, in trenton, new jersey and was an only child. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours. The irony of justice scalias california prison rant the. File in this wednesday, april 7, 2004 file photo, u. For a quarter of a century, scalia has been the conservative wings alpha dog. Scalia s dissent is full of the little touches that make his.
In his 29 years on the court, he achieved almost a cult following for dissents. Ruth, this is the penultimate draft of my dissent in the virginia mili tary institute. Scalia says that the courts holding while limited to the defense of marriage act is a sure sign that the majority is willing to declare gay marriage a. Windsor, two of the most important decisions of justice kennedys. Writings of the supreme courts wittiest, most outspoken justice scalia, antonin, ring, kevin.
Justice scalia delivered a scathing dissent saying that for the first time the supreme court was conferring constitutional rights to nonamericans. Looking at justice scalias opinions, dissents scalia weighed in on aereo, gps tracking, thermal imaging, drug dogs, gun rights, and dna. As justice scalia wrote in one of his most famous dissents. Scalia s dissent for the ages in the dna case june 4, 20 by jeffrey rosen some of supreme court justice antonin scalia s greatest opinions have involved his passionate defense of the. Supreme court justice antonin scalia was known for his dissents. And there was the historic battle in 2009 involving scalia and a presenting lawyer over the use of the word choate in a case argument. Highlights from justice antonin scalias opinions the new. Writing about justice antonin scalias writing is a daunting.
Together they had nine children and dozens of grandchildren. Scalia sat before the senate judiciary committee along with stephen breyer wednesday. Feb 14, 2016 justice scalias dissent was a fierce retort that claimed the majority view largely signed on to the socalled homosexual agenda. A legacy of landmark opinions and dissents, ring collects scalias most memorable opinions on free speech, separation of powers, race, religious freedom, the rights of the accused, abortion, and more. Below are excerpts from supreme court justice antonin scalia s dissenting opinion in the obamacare case king v. Antonin scalia is the supreme courts greatest writer. Even scalias dissenting opinions get major scrutiny. This book, published in 2004, compiles many of scalia s writings in the supreme courts decisions on such controversial topics as race, gender, abortion, the death penalty, free speech, religious freedom, and homosexuality.
1420 1279 1145 904 1122 1317 1395 852 376 1476 707 1277 255 524 1159 654 1092 1321 217 1221 294 344 948 491 1349 685 287 1102 956 1153 312 355 160 1459 931 842 1112 136 1464 784 146 675 497 1452 1215